First of all, lets look at how much your car is actually worth. Also known as the "trade value" of your car. This means how much the dealership would pay in hard cash for your car. This price is reached by having a look at one of those secret books. (They really aren't that secret, they are very expensive though - Glasses guide is £400 + vat per year and the full CAP black book system is £1500!!). Keep in mind these are "guides" though. So the dealer will get a guide from the book but also use his or her experience to set a value.
A well thumbed secret book
If your car is one that the dealer will not stock then they may phone another car trader to get an "underwrite". What this means is they ask another car trader to bid them a price on your car. (The trader will use the same method above). Traders tend to specialise in either older cars or perhaps specific brands or types. There are many local and literally hundreds of specialists listed in the car price guides underwriting everything from a £200 vauxhall to a £150,000 Ferrari. All the guide values are based on "excellent" condition. So if your pride and joy has a bashed bumper and two bald tyres we'll take that into account of course!
OK, so we've established the actual value of your car (subjectively). But that is different to your part exchange value. Every car for sale has a margin - that is, the difference between the price bought at and the price selling at. (Duh!)
Built into this margin is an amount that most dealers are prepared to give away to you as a discount or as an "over allowance". Over allowance is basically discount from the price of the car added to the value of your part exchange car. (You still with me??). Let me show you a simple example.
Car Sale Price: £20,000. Your car Value £8000
Margin in Car : £ 2,000 Part Exchange Value: £9000
Profit Retained:£1000 Over Allowance £1000
You may go into another dealership who offers you this deal:
Car Sale Price: £20,000 Your car Value £8000
Margin in Car: £ 5,000 Part Exchange Value: £9250
Profit Retained £ 3750 Over Allowance: £1250
So who got "the best deal" there then? Thats up to you to decide. As a dealer I'd be much happier with the second deal. As a customer you might be happier getting the extra £250 for your part exchange car. It just might be, however, that with £5000 margin the second car was too expensive to start with. Are you still happy with your extra £250? ;0))
So as you can see, in mathematical terms your part exchange value is almost infinately variable. The actual trade value of your car is subjective to to say the least. Then the over allowance applied depends on many other subjective factors - the margin in the car, the attitude of the dealer, how close they are to hitting targets, special deals available at the time, the phase of the moon* and a multitude of other factors.
So, as I said in the last post. First of all, buy the car, not just the deal. When you do look at the deal, look at the whole picture. Don't just be blinded by a stunning part exchange price!
Next time I'll tell you a bit about how car sales-people work. Sadly we don't have those magic Paul McKenna abilities to magic your money from your pocket but I'll let you into a few of the techniques we use. Shhhhh, don't tell everyone though!
Until then, keep your wallet close!
*Maybe not the moon in fairness






